The common answer is every three to five years. That's a reasonable average and a bad decision rule. Plenty of eight-year-old sites still produce work, and plenty of two-year-old sites never did.
Replace it when the numbers say so
- Traffic is flat or declining year over year
- Mobile visitors contact you far less often than desktop visitors
- Pages take more than three seconds to load on a phone
- You've added services or markets the site doesn't cover
- The site can't be edited without a developer
Patch or replace?
Small fixes can buy time when the structure is sound. When the foundation — page structure, speed, or platform — is the problem, patching keeps costing money without fixing it. That's when a new build pays for itself.
What a new site should keep
- Your domain name
- Any pages that already rank, at the same address or redirected properly
- Your reviews, photos of real work, and the content customers actually read
Replacing a site is also the right moment to add the service and location pages the old one never had.
Want a website like these built for your business?
Tell us what you need and we'll scope a new site for your market.
Start Your Website Project