The most expensive mistake when replacing a local business website isn't a bad design. It's a good new site that launches without a migration plan and takes years of search visibility down with it.
Measure the old site before it goes away
Export every URL. Pull traffic and ranking data for each one. Note which pages have inbound links. You cannot protect what you haven't documented.
Decide the fate of every old URL
- Keep — same URL on the new site, with a better page
- Merge — combine into a stronger page, redirect the old URL
- Expand — split a page that was trying to cover too much
- Retire — redirect to the closest relevant page, never to the homepage by default
Carry over the content that earns rankings
A cleaner design is good. Deleting the paragraphs that explain your services is not. If an old page ranks, understand why before leaving anything out of the new one.
Redirects before launch, not after
Every changed URL needs a 301 to its closest equivalent on the new site. Test them before launch. A week of 404s on your best pages is a real, measurable cost.
Watch the first month closely
Submit the new sitemap. Watch Search Console for crawl errors and coverage drops. Compare page-level traffic against your baseline weekly. Small dips are normal for a few weeks; sustained drops on specific pages mean something needs fixing.
Want a website like these built for your business?
Tell us what you need and we'll scope a new site for your market.
Start Your Website Project